Mobile Phones Document Police Killing Unarmed Man - Oakland, California

Regions: United States

Issues: Impunity, Juvenile justice, Police brutality

Tags: bart, california, oakland, oscar grant, police, San Francisco

As new information surfaces, I will update this post.  In the meantime, please forward this post and videos far and wide and join the calls for justice (see ColorLine's 5 Things You Can Do).

- UPDATE: 2.09.09, 9:00 EST: Officer Charged with Grant's Murder Released After Paying 10% of $3M Bail
- UPDATE: 1.16.09, 1:00 EST:  Former Officer Pleads Not Guilty to Murder
- UPDATE 1.14.09, 9:00 EST:  Former Officer that Killed Grant Arrested on Murder Warrant.
- UPDATE 1.13.09, 10:00 EST: Protesters in SF: 'We are Oscar Grant'
- UPDATE 1.12.09, 17:00 EST: Sign the pledge and join the calls for justice!
- UPDATE 1.12.09, 16:00 EST: New, better quality video.
- UPDATE 1.8.09, 10:00 EST: Report on Protest & arrests.
- UPDATE 1.7.09, 18:20 EST: Officer resigns.

At approximately 2:15 AM on New Year's Day, Oscar Grant, a young, unarmed black man was shot by police officers while laying face-down on a BART subway platform in Oakland, California.  Three separate videos, which are circulating online at a rapid pace, show various angles and stages of the incident.  The videos document Grant being restrained, laying face-down on the platform and with two officers restraining him - one with his knee on the back of Grant's neck.  Within seconds, the second officer restraining Grant rises to his feet, unholsters his gun and fires one shot into Grant's back. Grant died seven hours later in a nearby hospital.

Johannes Mehserle, the two-year veteran BART police officer that fatally shot Oscar Grant, has yet to give his account of the shooting - publicly or to investigators.  The San Francisco Chronicle reports that Mehserle is "being kept under wraps and moved from place to place after receiving a number of death threats."  They also report that if Mehserle is charged with a crime in Grant's shooting, it would be the first time in 20 years that an on-duty officer had been charged in a fatal shooting in Alameda County.

Oakland is the 44th largest city in the United States and has a reputation as one of the most dangerous cities in the country - a dubious distinction as the 5th worst city of violent crime by the 2008 Congressional Quarterly Press publication.  It is also known for systemic police abuse and misconduct.  A former WITNESS partner, Ella Baker Center, leads Bay Area PoliceWatch, a campaign since 1995 that works to protect the community from police misconduct and advocate for the creation and implementation of restorative policing practices (please see more of their video advocacy work here and here).

As I write, there is a memorial service for Oscar Grant and organizers are mobilizing for a protest this afternoon at the Fruitvale BART station, where Grant was murdered.  Additionally, John Burris, the Grant's family's attorney, has sued Oakland police by filing a $25 million civil rights suit in federal court.  As new information surfaces, I will update this post.  In the meantime, please forward this post and video far and wide and join the calls for justice. 

Additional links and resources
IndyBay's, the Indymedia hub for the Bay Area, video interview with Karina Vargas, eyewitness who documented the incident with video.  She notes how an officer tried to get her camera and her viewpoint as she was just a few feet away during the entire incident.

Facebook Group Page for Oscar Grant - latest updates and news.

San Francisco Chronicle's "BART shooting captured on video"

 


Comments

Hello fellow protesters!

Are we going to show our outrage over the shooting death of four Oakland police officers? Are we REALLY openminded and wanting justice and change for ALL? Or are we filled with bias and pseudo-intellectual rhetoric designed for our own spurious agenda and desire for avant-gardism?


I know I am late ringing in

I know I am late ringing in on this, and no I am not from California. However, I feel compelled to share my opinion. I have the utmost respect for all law enforcement officers and military personnel. They perform duties which I could never carry out, make split second decisions, and are out numbered by the general public they protect. Because of this, I don’t think the general public has room to judge an incident which we cannot begin to understand. This is not to say I feel the officer was in the right shooting Grant. I’m simply stating, unless you’ve been in a situation, how can you determine what is right and wrong? Is it tragic someone died? Absolutely, no negation. I feel for Grant’s family. I also feel for family of the BART officers involved. As cheesy as it sounds, when I heard of this, the movie A Few Good Men came to mind. Read the following and see if any leeway avails itself in your opinion.

I have a greater responsibility than you can possibly fathom. You have the luxury of not knowing what I know. That my existence, while grotesque and incomprehensible to you, saves lives. You don't want the truth because deep down in places you don't talk about at parties you want me, you need me. I have neither the time nor the inclination to explain myself to a man who rises and sleeps under the blanket of the very freedom I provide and then questions the manner in which I provide it.


Great

Great.Who is going to hold these guys accountable? For all this needless loss of life. It looks pretty clear from the video. Who are these guys in these police departments? Good job Hub and Witness. I always knew we needed you. But, it is too late when it had to come to this. And, $25M in taxpayer money to pay for these guys' wrong doing? Like which taxes are going to pay for that? Will the court case be a just one? Or will somebody get off the hook like in NYC last year? We've got a big problem America! There are too many holes in these systems. This feels kind of like a developing country, not the super power of the free world. We need better ways to hold everyone accountable everywhere, including us voters and taxpayers who haven't paid close enough attention all these years to the people we're trusting and giving our money to. Clearly, from some of the comments, we don't have consensus in our own minds about what was right and wrong about this situation. That is part of the problem. When I was a kid with my toy pistols, I definitely learned that shooting in the back was a big cowardly no no. Like hitting my sisters!


That person dressed as a cop

That person dressed as a cop might be completely disconnected from his true self and discharges his frustration on that poor kid. That person dressed as a cop is nothing but a scared little child who lived/lives a tough life, physical or psychological, or both. That cop lacks love and sees on that poor kid an opportunity to release his piled up anger and shoots him. I beleive the source of all violence are fear and lack of love that comes from disconnection from our true selves.


That person dressed as a cop

It's still murder, murder, murder,murder, murder! Stop all the 'mights.' If we use that as excuse everyone would be dead! That person has no business being a cop. They're not the only one's having a bad day. Oneofus, you're one silly sentimental.


Police Killing Unarmed Man

Police brutality has always been there, especially against minorities. If not for videos they would all be getting away with their crimes. The Bush Administrations love of torture and arrogance in ignoring the Constitution and the Bill of Rights; must give these brutes an inflated ego too. It's time cops start doing hard time for their crimes.
Peace and love,
Tammi Dee Voytek


Police Brutality

I agree 1000% with the comment made by Tammi Dee Voytek. Most police think that because they have a badge they can do whatever they want and get away with it and most of the time it involves a white cop beating an unarmed black man. You see white men are afraid of black men and always have been and now that we have a black president the white man feels inferior and will do anything to get his power back. My prayers go out to the Grant family and I hope they get some kind of justice.


ITS REALLY SAD

Its really sad to got this piece of infor that, a policeman who are suporpose to save lives and properities shot unarmed person.This is really unjust.The law must take it curse he must be punish.


No ones perfect, not me not you not cops.

in response to reply to jesse-have you ever been raped or had to deal with someone who has? some pain is not temporary.

in response to the video- Before judging you have to kno the story on both ends. Honestly tho its 2 in the fucking morning, those guys were detained for a reason.. The guy that was shot & his friend should have gone home instead they wantd to stick around and try &tlk to the cops come on-dont fkng wandr around.. that was a threat to the deputies.(profiling will always be around & it works 99%of the time) im sorry to hear he got shot. But there are diff reasons as to why the police officer shot him. Seems like it was an accident. Wrong place at the wrong time.. his ass should of been home instead of the streets at 2am.
ANYWAYS THE MEDIA ALWAYS OVER DO IT- THEY LEAVE A LOT OF SHIT OUT..

ppl jst have a bad taste in their mouths when it comes to cops... let me tell you somthng if you thnk they are corrupt(which they arent-mayb a couple but no ones perfect) government/politics is worst..


I guess I missed the memo

I guess I missed the memo that said there was a time limit for people to be outside. We are allowed to me out 24 hours a day, be it 2 am or 2 pm. There is no law that says other wise. If that law is ever passed I will be the first in the streets to protest. We are getting too use to our rights being taken away to the point where we defend the fact that we have no rights.

You do not know the story of this kid, who is to say he does not have a night job or is on his way back from a late church event. My point is, you just do not know. You can not say he was a bad kid just by looking at this video. His friend could have been the one who start this and he jumped in to help. You just do not know.

The real issue with this shooting is not his color it is simply the fact that this kid was already on the ground with 4 other trained police officers around him. If it takes that many officers to take down one kid and they still had to shot him, then I think we should really be looking at the police department and there lack of training. Two officers should have been more than enough, police officers are supposed to be well trained people that are tough to handle situation like these, if 4 of them could not do that job then there training is lacking and the department needs to be looked at.

I was a security guard back when I was 22 and we were put in some of the worst areas but we also got very good training and even when someone had a gun we always manage to talk our way out of it and dealt with the person correctly. 4 Security guards would have done much better than these cops. These guys are cops and if security guards are getting better communications training than cops then I say again, we need to look at the entire department.